So Archbishop Akinola of Nigeria, the African bishop who is most outspoken and activist in his condemnation of the Episcopal Church of late, sent a long letter to all his bishops about the trials and tribulations of recent Anglican history, and his struggle to bear faithful witness in these difficult times. You can read it here. (Thinking Anglicans rocks my world.)
A new story in the Church Times (UK) argues convincingly that this letter was largely written by Martyn Minns, an English priest and, since last year, a bishop in the Anglican Church of Nigeria, serving conservative evangelical Episcopalians.
Conservative leaders in the global North (North America and Europe) have insisted repeatedly, over the years, that they aren’t putting words in the mouths of their African allies – that they simply want to play a liberative, empowering role in their alliances with Anglicans in the global South – that the African bishops who support them are speaking their own convictions.
I believe that sometimes Northern conservatives have meant this, in all sincerity. But when your African allies just don’t put things quite as eloquently as you’d like them to, what are you gonna do?
Thinking Anglicans links this pithy commentary on this story.
*Â * Â * Â * Â * Â * Â *
I’ve been thinking about this, while enjoying my Saturday morning shower (without Zag – yay, Tilt’s home!), and I realized I have a little more to say. It seems, from the comments on Thinking Anglicans and elsewhere, that a lot of folks on the left are reading this incident as revealing once and for all that Southern Anglicans are just puppets for Northern conservatives. I would caution against that conclusion. I think it’s probably true that Akinola wouldn’t have put his name on the statement if he didn’t support it. And when I read statements from Ugandan archbishop Henry Orombi, whom I have met, they sound to me like his voice.
Just because Northern conservatives were involved in shaping this particular statement, doesn’t mean they always are or always have been. The reality is neither as simple as the Northern conservatives’ line that Southern Anglicans have freely and spontaneously come forward to support their positions and say exactly what they need and want them to say; nor as simple as what many Northern liberals believe – that Northern conservatives have manipulated Southern leaders to make sure they say exactly what they want and need them to say.
Teamwork indeed – complicated teamwork, with complex power dynamics, but teamwork nonetheless.